Treatment Spotlight: Breathwork and the Vagus Nerve — Your Built-In Brake Pedal

Stephanie Edmonds, RN, PsychotherapistOct 12, 2026
Common hand positions during breathwork

On this page

Before you read any further, try something with me.

Don’t change anything yet. Just notice your breath. Is it high in your chest or low in your belly? Fast or slow? Are you holding it a little, the way so many of us do when we’re concentrating on a screen?

Whatever you noticed is perfect. There’s no right answer. You’ve just done the first step of breathwork: paying attention.

Now picture this. It’s 2 a.m. and your eyes snap open. Your heart is pounding and you’re not even sure why. Someone once told you to “just take a deep breath,” so you try. You pull in a huge gulp of air, then another. Suddenly you feel dizzy, your chest is tight, and now you’re more panicked than when you started.

If that sounds familiar, I want you to know two things. You’re not bad at breathing. And the advice wasn’t wrong so much as incomplete. How you breathe, how fast and when you start all matter a great deal, especially when your nervous system has been shaped by trauma.

This is the next stop in our Treatment Spotlight series. We’ve explored Somatic Therapy, Sensorimotor Psychotherapy and Trauma-Sensitive Yoga and Movement. This time, I’ve organized things around the questions people ask me most about breathing, so feel free to jump to the one that’s on your mind.

“Why does my breathing change when I’m stressed?”

Think about the last time you opened an email you were dreading, or heard a door slam unexpectedly. Chances are you held your breath for a second, then started breathing fast and high in your chest.

That’s your alarm system at work, and it’s a brilliant adaptation. Quick, shallow breathing floods your body with oxygen so you’re ready to run or fight.

The trouble is that after trauma, the alarm doesn’t always switch off. As I described in Meet Your Four Bodyguards, your protective responses can stay on duty long after the danger has passed. Many people live with a low hum of shallow breathing and stop noticing it altogether.

Here’s the hopeful part. Most of your nervous system runs on autopilot. You can’t decide how fast your heart beats. But breathing is the one part of the system you can also steer. Your brain changes your breath, and your breath also sends messages back to your brain about how safe things are right now.

“What is the vagus nerve, anyway?”

The vagus nerve is a long nerve that wanders from your brainstem down to your heart, lungs and gut. One of its main jobs is to slow your heart down, a bit like easing your foot onto the brake pedal.

You’ve probably felt it without knowing it. Think about the big, shuddering sigh that comes at the end of a good cry, or the long breath out when you finally sit down after a hard day. That’s your body reaching for the brake on its own.

Here’s how it works. Your heart speeds up slightly each time you breathe in and slows down slightly each time you breathe out. When you slow your breathing and let the exhale be a little longer, the brake gets more time to do its job.

A quick note, in case you’ve read about this online. You may have come across “ventral vagal” and “dorsal vagal” states, part of a popular framework called polyvagal theory. Earlier this year, 39 researchers who study the vagus nerve and the heart published a strong critique of some of that theory’s specific claims. The science is still being debated. What isn’t in doubt is simpler and still useful: slow, steady breathing nudges your body toward rest. You don’t need the fancy theory for the tool to work, and feeling safe and connected matters as much as it always has.

“Does breathwork actually work?”

As always in this series, I want to be straight with you about the evidence. Here’s where things stand.

What we know

  • Slow breathing shifts the body toward rest. A large review of 223 studies found that slow breathing consistently increases a type of heart rate variability linked to the body’s calming system. It showed up during practice, right after a single session, and after programs lasting several weeks. The authors call it a low-cost, low-tech tool with few side effects expected.
  • Breathwork can ease stress, anxiety and low mood. A 2023 meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials found small-to-moderate reductions in all three.
  • A few minutes a day can help. In a 2023 randomized study, people practised for just five minutes daily over a month. A technique called cyclic sighing (you’ll find it below) lifted mood more than mindfulness meditation and slowed people’s resting breathing rate. Both approaches helped with anxiety.

What we’re still learning

  • How much it helps with trauma specifically. A 2025 meta-analysis of yogic breathing (pranayama) for PTSD, depression and related conditions found small, short-term benefits compared with no treatment, but no clear advantage over established therapies.
  • Which styles are safest. Fast, forceful breathing techniques were linked to more side effects in that same review.
  • How strong the studies are. Across this research, study quality is mixed, and most trials are short.

My take: Breathwork is a valuable skill and part of your scaffolding. It isn’t a stand-alone treatment for trauma, and it doesn’t replace trauma-focused work like EMDR. What it does is give you a way to steady yourself so the deeper work can happen.

“Why do breathing exercises sometimes make me feel worse?”

This is one of the most common things I hear, and it makes a lot of sense.

For some people, focusing on the breath feels like turning toward the alarm itself. This is especially true if your breathing was restricted during a traumatic experience, or if you live with asthma or panic attacks. And big, deep “fill your lungs” breaths can tip you into over-breathing, which makes you light-headed and even more alarmed. That’s exactly what happened in the 2 a.m. scene at the top of this post.

I’d also gently steer you away from intense practices, like rapid “power breathing” or long breath holds, as a starting point in trauma recovery. They can rev you up rather than settle you, and the research suggests side effects are more common with those styles.

If breathwork makes things feel worse, that isn’t proof you’re doing it wrong. It’s useful information about your nervous system, and something we can explore together.

“Okay, so where do I start?”

Think of this as a menu. Pick whatever feels most doable today. You can stop at any time, and any choice you make is the right one.

If you’d like something very simple: the Longer Exhale Breathe in at whatever pace feels comfortable. Then, if you like, let your exhale be just a little longer than your inhale. No counting, no forcing. Try three or four breaths and notice your shoulders, jaw or belly.

If you want a quick reset: the Physiological Sigh Breathe in through your nose. At the top, take one more small sip of air through your nose. Then let it all out slowly through your mouth, like a long sigh. Two or three rounds are plenty. This is the same pattern as cyclic sighing from the study above.

If focusing on your breath feels like too much, try a side door:

  • Hum, sing or count out loud. It naturally lengthens your exhale without you having to think about it. Singing along in the car absolutely counts.
  • Keep your eyes open and look around the room as you breathe.
  • Add movement, like raising your arms as you breathe in and lowering them as you breathe out.
  • Start with your feet. Feeling the floor beneath you can be a gentler anchor than the breath.

“How does this fit into therapy?”

At Fera Verto, we use a 4-Stage Path to Recovery, and breathwork has a role in each stage:

  • Awareness: noticing how your breath changes when your alarm system fires, just like the experiment at the start of this post.

  • Skills Building: breathwork’s natural home. It becomes a portable tool you can use between sessions, before a hard conversation or stuck in traffic on the Queensway, helping to widen your window of tolerance.

  • Processing: a reliable way to touch the brake helps you stay present during deeper work like EMDR or somatic therapy, without being swept away.

  • Growth: over time, your breath can shift from something that seems to work against you into a steady, lifelong resource.

Within my Integrated Modular Therapy approach, breathwork is one module among many. We use it alongside somatic work, parts work, DBT skills or EMDR, and we shape it around your body instead of handing you a one-size-fits-all app.

A pattern I see often is that the first win isn’t dramatic. It’s the moment someone notices their breath tightening in the middle of a stressful phone call, lets one exhale get a little longer, and realizes they have a say in what happens next. That small moment is what we build on.

The Takeaway

Your breath has worked hard to keep you ready for danger. The shallow, held, quick breathing was a brilliant adaptation, and it got you through. With patience and the right approach, that same breath can become the way you remind your body that you’re safe now.

If you’d like help finding a breathing practice that works with your nervous system instead of against it, I offer a free 30-minute consultation. We’ll explore what fits your body, your history and your life.

Heal The Why Behind The What!

Try this today: go back to the experiment at the top of this post. Notice your breath again, and if you’d like, let one exhale be a little slower than the last. Has anything shifted since you started reading?

References & Further Reading

  • Laborde, S., et al. (2022). Effects of voluntary slow breathing on heart rate and heart rate variability: A systematic review and a meta-analysis. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 138, 104711. Link
  • Fincham, G. W., Strauss, C., Montero-Marin, J., & Cavanagh, K. (2023). Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials. Scientific Reports, 13. PMC
  • Balban, M. Y., et al. (2023). Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal. Cell Reports Medicine, 4(1), 100895. PMC
  • Mütze, C., Mitzinger, D., & Haller, H. (2025). Effectiveness of pranayama for mental disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 16. Link
  • Grossman, P., et al. (2026). Why the polyvagal theory is untenable: An international expert evaluation of the polyvagal theory. Clinical Neuropsychiatry, 23(1), 100–112. PMC